With a tire that can tackle a wide range of weather conditions, you will no longer have to worry about changing your tires! If you are looking for this kind of peace of mind, Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive tires vs Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tires are excellent winter certified all-season models.
Find out more about both of these models thanks to this detailed comparison brought to you by blackcircles Canada.
How do the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady compare?
Both tire models are specially made for a similar type of driver: one that wants to take advantage of good traction year round, without having to change tires. In fact, both promise good grip levels both in the winter and the summer, along with optimal durability.
On the one hand, you have the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tire, with a name that is already well established. Launched in August 2017, this model was innovating at the time, with the all-new soybean oil based tread compound, the only one in its category. It provided the tire with even more flexibility, helping the tire maintain the same levels of traction even in colder temperatures.
This is also why it has received the winter certification, just as the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol indicates. This tire is just as well suited to sedans and coupés as it is for crossovers, SUVs and minivans, with dimensions ranging from 15- to 20- inches.
On the other hand, the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive tire is part of the new available models on the market. Offered since 2022, it is already forging its path as one of the best in its category, offering both high performance and a remarkably comfortable driving experience.
This tire is perfectly suited to crossovers, SUVs and light trucks, and it is also available in dimensions ranging from 17- to 22- inches. Touring cars will be perfectly equipped with the Cinturato WeatherActive high-end tire model.
With this new tire, Pirelli relies on a directional tread. The Assurance WeatherReady has approached things from a different angle, with an asymmetrical tread design. As we will see, this creates a few differences between the two models. But first things first, let’s take a closer look at each tire’s specs.
Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive: Specs
With the all-new Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive tire, you will take advantage of the brand’s latest innovations, used to create a high-quality tire. Here are some of the features it offers:
- A new and innovative polymer/resin compound
- A directional tread that focuses on a comfortable and quiet driving experience
- Deep continuous sipes
- A zigzag shaped central groove
- “Trumpet” shaped lateral grooves
- A balanced tread
With this new tire, Pirelli relies on a new compound that offers a maximum of flexibility in cold temperatures, but also optimal durability in the summer. This means that performance levels are maintained in all weather conditions and in a wide range of temperatures.
The directional tread design obviously helps with quick and efficient water and slush evacuation. There are also "trumpet" shaped lateral grooves that help direct water out and away from the tire surface. As for the central part of the tread, the zigzag shaped groove ensures good traction performance on wet or snow covered roads.
On top of great performance on wet roads, this tread is also designed to help reduce noise and to boost comfort levels. The rounded edges, the smooth transition from one block to the next and an optimised void ratio all contribute to these qualities as well.
Made for durable performance, the Pirelli tire has a 3- rib treadblock tread design that helps ensure even tread wear. When it comes to the sipes, they are deep and offer good traction throughout the tire’s lifespan. This not only helps make it a durable tire, but also one that offers great performance on snow.
Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady: Specs
Another sure bet in this category is the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tire, which also offers advanced features that will provide you with a feeling of safety and confidence at the wheel at all times:
- An asymmetrical tread design
- Sweeping traction grooves
- The Weather Reactive technology
- The TredLock technology
- A specialized compound made with soybean oil
- Intermediate grooves with biting edges
The tread is designed to provide you with maximum grip levels with the road. You will find four circumferential grooves and an asymmetrical lateral groove design for efficient water evacuation.
The evolving grooves will not only help evacuate water, they also widen as the tire wears, to ensure that they do not lose their initial performance levels.
When you need a maximum of traction –no matter if it is on wet roads or snow covered roads-, the Weather Reactive technology is here to help. In fact, it combines two elements: the evolving traction grooves and the TredLock technology, which allows for biting edges to be created at the center of the tire and on the tread’s exterior grooves.
By doing so, the Weather Reactive technology provides you with smooth road handling while cornering and offers even better grip when you need added traction.
Certified for severe snow conditions, this tire obviously has a rugged tread that can tackle these conditions as well. This innovative tread compound integrates soybean oil that allows the tread to remain flexible even in cold temperatures, without compromising on durability when it gets warmer. Moreover, you can rely on intermediate ribs with zigzag biting edges that will allow you to remain stable even on slippery road surfaces.
Choose between the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive tire and the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady tire
Now that you know a little more about their specific qualities, which tire is the best one for you in this friendly duel between the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady?
On the one hand, the Pirelli tire focuses on quick and efficient water evacuation with the V- shaped grooves. The directional tread also already places it among the best of its category! It is a tire that truly aims at providing you with a safe driving experience, with superior traction on rainy days or when the snow begins to melt.
On the other hand, the Goodyear’s asymmetrical tread also offers water evacuating grooves. Although it remains very safe in these conditions, traction on wet roads is not its main strength.
Among other things, what makes it one of the best is the winter traction it offers, and which helps it stand out from its rivals. In fact, this tire will provide you with the necessary feeling of confidence at the wheel, so that you can drive safely on snow covered surfaces or on a day with freezing rain, for example. It will provide you with maximum traction thanks to the TredLock technology, and the soybean oil based compound makes it a very flexible tire as well.
Moreover, the two tires are designed to offer both versatility and a remarkable lifespan, and both have the same UTQG rating (Uniform Tire Quality Grading) of 700, which is an excellent number.
As for the warranty, Pirelli offers a limited warranty on tread life of 100,000 km, while Goodyear offers a 95,000 km warranty. Both also offer a 30- day satisfaction guarantee.
Comparing road handling
Other than the traction performance they offer, what kind of road handling do both tires offer? On the one hand, critics seem to love Pirelli for the balanced road handling it offers. Steering response while cornering is impressive, and so is the feeling of control behind the wheel.
Moreover, the tire was designed to reduce noises while driving. Although some noises can be heard at lower speeds, the ingenuous design does provide you with a very comfortable and refined driving experience.
When it comes to Goodyear, critics also seem to appreciate the good directional response, although the overall road handling seems to be less refined than with Pirelli. Nevertheless, you will enjoy a dynamic and precise driving experience, along with a feeling of being in control.
Between both models, you will certainly notice that Pirelli is in a more expensive price range. This is mostly due to the more refined driving experience it offers, but also the speed ratings, which are generally superior.
In fact, The Assurance WeatherReady is mostly offered with H, T and V speed ratings. The Scorpion WeatherActive offers a few dimensions with the H speed rating, but most of the speed ratings it offers are V, W, and even Y.
All in all, the Pirelli tire offers superior performance levels on wet roads and a more comfortable ride, while the Goodyear tire stands out first and foremost with the greater winter traction and sportier driving experience it offers.
So, everything will depend on what you are looking for! Purchase the one that is best suited to your needs at the best possible price with blackcircles Canada!
Consult the winter buying guide
